Supreme Court to refer bill on magistrates' pensions to Constitutional Court
The judges of the Supreme Court unanimously decided on Friday to refer to the Constitutional Court the new bill of the Bolojan Government on the reform of the pensions of magistrates.
The magistrates were called by Supreme Court president Lia Savonea to express their position, within the Joint Sections, regarding the legislative draft on the special pensions of judges and prosecutors. All 102 judges present at the meeting voted in favor of referring the matter to the Constitutional Court.
Court spokesman Victor Alistar said the law was based 'on a counterfactual reality' and lacked data on its economic impact. He explained that, in the view of the United Sections, the bill is incompatible with constitutional rules, as its urgency was not demonstrated and the reference to milestone 215 of the NRRP was taken out of context. According to European Commission documents, that milestone concerned overtaxation proposals, not retirement modalities, which had already been assessed as fulfilled, Alistar argued.
Among the intrinsic reasons for unconstitutionality, Victor Alistar listed the law's ambiguity and unpredictability.
'The law violates the constitutional obligations of clarity of regulation to ensure predictability and predictability enshrined in Article 1, paragraphs 3 and 5 of the Romanian Constitution. Specifically, the law uses legal terms that do not exist in the normative fund and are not defined in the content of the present normative proposal, creating ambiguity and unpredictability,' Alistar noted.
In addition, the Supreme Court considers that the project discriminates against magistrates in relation to other categories that benefit from special pensions.
Victor Alistar argued that the new law undermines the principle of legal certainty by abruptly changing magistrates' status without transition. He said that 66% of judges face sudden increases in retirement age, while the law also discriminates against magistrates compared to other service pension categories. Unlike others, magistrates' pensions are capped at 70% of net income, far below the 80% or more applied elsewhere, despite their constitutional status and relatively small budgetary impact.
In a press release, the Supreme Court listed several reasons why the law is unconstitutional: it discriminates against magistrates, violates judicial independence, effectively eliminates service pensions, contradicts CJEU, ECHR and CCR jurisprudence, ignores binding CCR decisions, and uses ambiguous terms that fail the standard of clarity required in a rule-of-law state.
The Court warned that the law de facto cancels service pensions, leaving future magistrates worse off than under the public pension system. It also criticized the explanatory memorandum for lacking financial substantiation, pointing out that magistrates represent only a small share of the 200,000 beneficiaries of service pension, with defense and public order accounting for 90% and a budget of over 14 billion RON in 2024, compared to 2.2 billion RON for all other categories.
Last week, the Government approved the draft piece of legislation raising the retirement age of magistrates to 65 and capping pensions at 70% of net salary. The Superior Council of Magistracy issued a negative opinion, while judges and prosecutors requested pensions closer to their last salary. Prime Minister Ilie Bolojan insisted on the 70% cap. The first draft of the reform was already declared unconstitutional by the CCR on October 20, following a complaint from the High Court of Cassation and Justice. AGERPRES (RO - writing by: Eusebi Manolache; EN - writing by: Simona Klodnischi)
The content of the www.agerpres.ro website has the exclusive purpose of public informing.
All the information published on this website by AGERPRES is protected by relevant legal dispositions.
It is forbidden to copy, reproduce, recompile, decompile, distribute, publish, display, modify, create derived components or products or full services, as well as any exploitation of the site's content.
Details in the section Terms of Use. If you are interested in picking up AGERPRES news items, please contact the Marketing Department – marketing@agerpres.ro.
The use of the Comments section entails your obligation to respect the AGERPRES terms and conditions in regards to the publishing of comments on the www.agerpres.ro.
Other news in category
ICR: European Day of Languages marked with events in 13 cities worldwide
The Romanian Cultural Institute (ICR) is marking the European Day of Languages with a series of events taking place from 24 September to 15 October in 13 cities around the world: Bucharest, Beijing, Lisbon, London, Madrid, Prague, Tokyo, Warsaw, New York, Stockholm, Tel Aviv, Athens and Belgrade. Organised within EUNIC clusters in partnership with European ins
Wooden churches of Maramures, part of UNESCO World Heritage, displayed in photo exhibition
A travelling photographic art exhibition 'Treasures of Romania - UNESCO World Heritage in Maramures' by photographer Tudorel Ilie, will be hosted by the Victor Gorduza County Museum of Mineralogy in Baia Mare throughout November. As many as eight wooden churches, some hundreds of years old, from Maramures County are part of the UNESCO World Heritage.
Siegfried Muresan: We'll continue to put public finances in order, reduce waste; this doesn't mean austerity
Prime Minister-designate Siegfried Muresan said on Tuesday that reducing unnecessary spending and making public spending more efficient are not austerity measures, but measures of responsibility, adding that he will continue efforts to reduce waste. 'Let's not confuse putting an end to waste with austerity. In recent years, the term 'austerity'
MNAR to host exhibition of costumes and textile objects from The Metropolitan Museum of Art donation
The exhibition 'Celebrating The Met. Highlights from the Gift of The Metropolitan Museum of Art to Muzeul Textilelor,' organised as part of the 'Muzeul Textilelor - Totul Se leaga'/'Textile Museum - Everything is Connected' project, will open to the public at the National Museum of Art of Romania (MNAR) on Friday. The exhibition present
President Dan says General Assembly participation offers opportunity to present Romania's views on regional security
AGERPRES special correspondent Florin Stefan reports: The participation in this session of the UN General Assembly represents an opportunity for us to present Romania's point of view on regional security in particular and to be in contact with other leaders on topics of interest to us, President Nicusor Dan stated on Monday evening in New York. Asked at a
President Dan meets members of the Romanian community in New York
AGERPRES special correspondent to New York Florin Stefan reports: President Nicusor Dan met on Monday evening with several dozen members of the Romanian community in New York, telling them that he would like to make use of their professional experience in a way that would benefit both the United States and Romania. The President on Monday evening inaugurated t
President Nicusor Dan meets former US ambassadors, thanks them for promoting Romania
President Nicusor Dan met former US ambassadors to Romania in New York, thanking them for their contribution to promoting Romania and their work to strengthen and deepen bilateral relations. The president said the US-Romania partnership has been an 'enduring achievement' built on 'solid foundations'. 'I met in New York with f
PM-designate Siegfried Muresan: PSD leadership does not want an end to political crisis
Prime Minister-designate Siegfried Muresan on Monday criticised the Social Democratic Party (PSD) leadership for deciding not to support his proposed government before seeing its programme or holding talks, saying the move would prolong Romania's political crisis. Muresan said PSD has a choice between supporting his proposed government and breaking the pol
Alleged Order of Malta diplomatic ID bearing Calin Georgescu's name found - judicial sources
An alleged diplomatic ID bearing the name of Calin Georgescu, apparently issued by the Order of Malta, was found by investigators at his villa in Mogosoaia, judicial sources told AGERPRES. The alleged ID is headed 'DIPLOMATIC ID' - Order of Malta, Sovereign Order Hospitalliers of Saint John of Jerusalem - and bears the name of 'senator' Calin G
UPDATE Social Democratic Party National Standing Bureau decides not to support Siegfried Muresan government
The Social Democratic Party (PSD) National Standing Bureau on Monday decided not to support the government to be formed by Prime Minister-designate Siegfried Muresan. 'The National Standing Bureau of the Social Democratic Party decided today not to vote for the Bolojan 2.0 Government. This recommendation from the National Standing Bureau will be submitted
Romanian pupils win four medals at Balkan Olympiad in Informatics
Romanian pupils won four medals - one gold, two silver and one bronze - at the 33rd edition of the Balkan Olympiad in Informatics, which took place in Tirana, Albania, from 14 to 20 September. The medal winners were Stefan-Catalin Savu from Ion Luca Caragiale National College in Ploiesti, who won a gold medal; Matei Neacsu from the International Computer Scien
PM-designate Muresan: I will propose a voluntary merger of communes in Romania and a reform of state-owned companies
Prime Minister-designate Siegfried Muresan announced that he would propose in the governing programme a voluntary merger of communes, thus taking over the model implemented in the Republic of Moldova. 'Unfortunately, politicians in the past have always had a superiority complex in relation with the Republic of Moldova. However, today, after Maia Sandu has
Decree appointing Siegfried Muresan as prime minister-designate published in Official Journal
The decree appointing Siegfried Muresan as prime minister-designate was published in the Official Journal of Romania on Monday. President Nicusor Dan designated MEP Siegried Muresan, as prime minister on Thursday, following consultations at the Cotroceni Palace with the leaders and representatives of the parties and political groups in Parliament.
PM-designate Siegfried Muresan to ask Parliament for ministers' hearings to last at least an hour
Prime Minister-designate Siegfried Muresan said he would ask Parliament's leadership for the hearings of the proposed ministers to last at least 60 minutes. Muresan told RFI Romania on Monday that he had 'never' liked 'rush-through' hearings. He underscored that MPs must have the opportunity for a 'serious dialogue' with the candida
President Dan: Maryhill Museum of Art, a true cultural bridge between Romania, the United States
President Nicusor Dan sent a message on Sunday at an event held at the Maryhill Museum of Art in Goldendale, Washington State, marking the 100th anniversary of the museum's opening, highlighting the institution's role in promoting Romanian culture and strengthening cultural relations between Romania and the United States. The message from the head of s








