logo logo

Agerpres – National News Agency: Current news with reliable information for a well-informed society.

Bucharest

Piaţa Presei Libere nr. 1, sector 1

Phone: +4 021.2076.110; +4 021.2076.105

[email protected]

Time to say goodbye: Will the EU ever abandon Daylight Saving Time? (enr)

Image

Brussels, April 4 /Agerpres/ - A move to end the twice-yearly clock change in the EU has been on the back burner for years. The Polish Presidency of the Council of the European Union has been pushing against the Brussels inertia to get that ball rolling again. Help might come from an unexpected corner: Trump and Musk.

Like clockwork, every year in late March the same spiel repeats itself. People confusedly ask each other whether the clocks go forward or back by one hour. Sleep is lost, appointments are missed: And like every year, millions of Europeans from Denmark to Croatia ask themselves: Do we really need daylight saving time (DST) - and what is it anyway?

The European Commission proposed abolishing the custom of seasonal clock changes in 2018 after nearly four million people in the bloc's then 28 member states - before the United Kingdom formally exited - gave their support in an open consultation. The Parliament backed the reform the following year, but it has since fallen into limbo after hitting opposition from some EU states.

Poland, which holds the bloc's rotating presidency until July, said it is time to put the issue back on the countries' agenda. The Polish presidency will hold technical talks with the member states at the end of April to check whether there is a chance of reaching an agreement on the abolition of the clock changes, EU sources said.

The practice of moving the clocks forward in spring to add an hour of light to the evening was carried out in some European countries on and off since World War I. It fell by the wayside when many European countries abandoned the measure as it became a reminder of the war itself. During the 1970s oil crisis it was brought back to save energy, and stayed.

European countries then introduced DST in the late 1970s or early 1980s. The EU first legislated on summer-time arrangements in 1980, with a directive that coordinated existing national practices. The aim was to help ensure the smooth functioning of the single market, the European Council explains on its website.

The current directive entered into force in 2001. Under its provisions, all member states switch to summer time on the last Sunday in March and back to their standard time (‘winter time') on the last Sunday in October.


Does daylight saving save anything?

The general idea was to save energy costs by 'winning' one hour of daylight in the evenings.

However, the actual energy-saving effect is controversial. The German Environment Agency summarised: 'How much energy is actually saved by switching to daylight saving time cannot be precisely determined, because: The change leads to lower consumption in some areas and higher consumption in others.'

That means that on the one hand, daylight is utilised more effectively during daylight saving time, resulting in electricity savings during the evening hours. On the other hand though, more heating energy is consumed due to earlier waking times during the cooler morning hours in spring and autumn.

Most studies point to a very low energy savings potential.


Losing sleep over DST

There is also the mounting evidence of detrimental health effects of the time change - both in northern and southern European countries:

'There's a huge amount of evidence suggesting that changing the clock biannually is bad for human health, bad for animals, bad for road traffic, and has very little beneficial attributes. And it's also a huge inconvenience,' said Irish EU lawmaker Seán Kelly, one of the most vocal proponents of eradicating clock changes.

In 2017, a Danish study showed that 11 percent more people suffer from depression in the week after we switch from summer time to winter time compared to other weeks of the year. 'It has been directly demonstrated that those who are prone to depression can experience the sudden onset of darkness as a trigger for the disease,' said Jorgen Bak, chairman of the Danish Association Against Daylight Saving Time.

In Spain, the best course of action would be to stick with the time zone closest to our meridian, which is winter time, said Gonzalo Pin, coordinator of the Sleep and Chronobiology Group of the Spanish Association of Pediatrics (AEP). 'Sudden time changes cause our neurohormonal system - cortisol, melatonin, serotonin, and cholesterol - which has its own biological cycle, to become significantly out of sync,' Pin emphasised.

But the scientific opinions are also not unanimous: Bulgarian neurologist Dr Diana Dechovska said in an interview for the Bulgarian News Agency BTA in 2022 that the human body is quite adaptable, and changing the time by one hour is generally not that stressful.

An average person needs 5 to 10 days to get used to the time change, she said. Dechovska quoted data according to which about only 5 percent of people suffer from more negative reactions to the time change. They may experience sleep disturbance that could lead to nervousness, irritability, reduced concentration, low mood. Older people and those with chronic illnesses are more susceptible to these adverse events, as their bodies are less adaptable.


Change: who wants it, and in which direction?

Although the European Commission proposed ending the time change about six and a half years ago, no agreement has yet been reached among the EU member states on this issue.

The proposal followed an online survey conducted in the summer of 2018, in which 4.6 million people participated. Of that number, 84 percent said they were in favor of putting an end to the bi-annual clock change.

However, only in Germany and Austria a significant number of people responded. Of the 4.6 million who responded, over 3.1 million were from Germany, over 260,000 from Austria, while the response in the other member states was very low. Germans overwhelmingly voted in favour of making summer time permanent.

The current Polish EU Presidency is informally examining whether it is possible to advance the proposal to abolish the time change but is aware that the proposal has so far received only limited support from the EU member states.

A spokeswoman for the EU Commission said: 'We believe that a coordinated solution is still achievable, and we encourage renewed discussions.'

Poland's Minister of Development and Technology Krzysztof Paszyk said the Commission's position was the result of his conversation with the EU Commissioner responsible for transport, Apostolos Tzitzikostas. 'We both agree that time changes in Europe should be stopped. The Polish presidency has full support for the actions in this matter,' the minister assured.

After his re-election, US President Donald Trump said he wanted to get rid of DST as 'inconvenient' and 'very costly' - although he has since tempered his tone, calling it a '50/50 issue'.

Trump's ally and tech billionaire Elon Musk jumped into the fray by asking his followers last month if they preferred an hour earlier or later - were the change to go ahead. A majority preferred a later sunrise and sunset all year.

However, it seems that similar enthusiasm is lacking among the EU countries. Denmark and Cyprus, which will take over the presidency of the EU Council after Poland, are also said to be uninterested in taking the matter forward.

In Denmark, Jorgen Bak hopes that Trump can get Europe to agree to abolish daylight saving time.

However, for the abolition to take place, the EU states would first need to agree on whether they want to adopt permanent daylight saving time or standard time.

In Bulgaria, there were calls from political parties to abolish summer time, and citizens seem to agree. Data from a 2018 EU poll showed that 80 percent of Bulgarian respondents said their overall experience with the clock change was either very negative or negative, while less than 20 percent enjoyed a positive or a very positive experience.

Italy, on the other hand, recently saw a petition with 350,000 signatories calling for making daylight saving time permanent. According to the Italian Society of Environmental Medicine (SIMA), one of the organisers, the adoption of daylight saving time has allowed for savings of 11.7 billion kWh over 10 years, which reduced energy bills for Italians by 2.2 billion Euro. Additionally, there has been a significant reduction in climate-altering emissions.

Albanians are in favour of the time change, partly due to the fact that the small Balkan country enjoys around 300 sunny days a year, which primarily results in saving electrical energy.

Others are more agnostic: In Romania, which regulated its switch to summer time in 1997, there is no debate or official initiatives calling for change.


It's astronomy, stupid

While often the problem may be the lack of political unity within the EU, in this case, the issue also has a geographical aspect, which cannot be overlooked.

There are three time zones in the European Union, the largest of which is Central Europe, from Poland in the east to Spain in the west.

If all countries in that time zone were to adopt, for example, summer time permanently, in Belgium, the Netherlands, and Denmark, the sun would rise only in the middle of the morning in winter, and in northwest Spain around 10 a.m.

If they were to adopt winter time as a permanent time, the sun would rise in eastern Poland as early as 3 in the morning in summer, and in Berlin at 3:44 a.m.

On the other hand, if countries in the west and north of the continent were to enter the Western European time zone, which would be natural, new complications would arise because, for example, France and Germany would fall into two different time zones.

For the moment, it seems that seasonal clock changes, despite all their drawbacks, are still the best compromise.

The content of this article is based on reporting by AFP, Agerpres, ANSA, ATA, BTA, dpa, EFE, HINA, PAP, Ritzau, as part of the European Newsroom (enr) project. AGERPRES (editing by: Mariana Ionescu)

Display count: 547

The content of the www.agerpres.ro website has the exclusive purpose of public informing.
All the information published on this website by AGERPRES is protected by relevant legal dispositions.
It is forbidden to copy, reproduce, recompile, decompile, distribute, publish, display, modify, create derived components or products or full services, as well as any exploitation of the site's content.
Details in the section Terms of Use. If you are interested in picking up AGERPRES news items, please contact the Marketing Department – [email protected].
The use of the Comments section entails your obligation to respect the AGERPRES terms and conditions in regards to the publishing of comments on the www.agerpres.ro.


Other news in category

English 16-05-2025 19:20

Albesti limestone - Romania's symbolic contribution to Europe Cross on Mount Feuerkogel

Romania contributed a rock emblematic for its national geoheritage to the Europe Cross that sits on the Feuerkogel mountain in Upper Austria, in a breathtaking natural setting. The monument erected in 2006 during the Austrian Presidency of the Council of the European Union was assembled from individual cubes, each representing an EU member state. This year, tw

English 16-05-2025 17:48

PresidentialElection2025/Expert Forum says campaign has driven wedge of social division and polarisation even deeper

Several NGOs, public policy and public governance think-tank Expert Forum included, called on Friday on the presidential candidates and their fan bases to refrain from unfounded accusations, aggressive rhetoric, discrimination, threats against the other camp, and any kind of provocative agitation, so as not to further inflame public opinion. 'The stakes of

English 16-05-2025 16:44

Power off: Where do EU member states stand on school smartphone bans? (enr)

From distraction to cyberbullying - smartphones and social media are blamed for a wide range of ills affecting students. While the EU is inching towards banning mobiles in schools some member states have already gone much farther. Children being glued to their smartphone screens at school, at home and at any point in between has become the new

English 16-05-2025 13:34

Projects worth more than 63 M euros to integrate the young with the labour market

Over 63 million euros are pre-contracted or already contracted for the development of projects dedicated to supporting the integration of young people into the labour market, the Ministry of Labour, Family, Youth and Social Solidarity (MMFTSS) informs in a post published on Friday on the institution's Facebook page. According to the same source, through th

English 16-05-2025 13:19

PresidentialElection2025/Diaspora turnout by 1:00 PM stands at around 50,000 voters

Around 50.000 voters cast their ballot in the second round of the presidential election, at polling stations abroad by Friday, 1:00 PM (Romanian time), according to real-time data provided by the Permanent Electoral Authority (AEP). According to AEP, 49,559 Romanian citizens voted in person from the opening of the polls on Thursday evening at 10:00 PM (Romania

English 16-05-2025 13:05

Night of Museums 2025, at its 21st edition on Saturday: exhibitions, concerts, movie screenings, recitals, workshops

More than 75 museums, bringing together 210 venues from all over the country, will participate on Saturday in the 21st edition of the Night of Museums 2025, with the Ministry of Culture officially supporting the event for the first time. An impressive number of 500 specialists in the field of heritage and museum education will organize 677 activities aimed at

English 16-05-2025 12:33

Romania-Poland Cultural Season: Urban installations at Romanian Design Week and Lodz Design Festival

Two public space installations, the result of a year of Romanian-Polish cooperation, will be presented in Bucharest, by Romanian Design Week, and in Lodz, by the Lodz Design Festival. The installations are part of the project 'Design is our shared language,' organised within the Romania-Poland / Poland-Romania Cultural Season 2024-2025, whose slogan is

English 16-05-2025 11:36

PresidentialElection2025/Diaspora turnout by 11:00 AM stands at over 23,300 voters

Over 23,300 voters turned out to vote at polling stations abroad by Friday at 11:00 AM (Romanian time) to vote in the second round of the presidential election, according to real-time data provided by the Permanent Electoral Authority (AEP). According to AEP, from the opening of the polls on Thursday evening at 10:00 PM (Romanian time) until Friday at 11:00 AM

English 16-05-2025 09:31

PresidentialElection2025/AEP: Over 7,000 voters turn out to vote in diaspora by 9:00 AM

Over 7,000 voters had turned out at the polls abroad by Friday morning at 9:00 AM (Romanian time) to vote in the second round of the presidential election, according to real-time data provided by the Permanent Electoral Authority (AEP). According to AEP, since the opening of the polls - Thursday evening at 10:00 PM Romanian time - until Friday morning at 9:00

English 16-05-2025 08:32

PresidentialElections2025/Friday is the last day of electoral campaign, first day of voting in the diaspora

Friday is the last day in which the two candidates in the final race for the Cotroceni seat can still campaign. According to the election calendar, the campaign for the electoral competitors who reached the second round of voting began on May 9, after the Constitutional Court of Romania (CCR) validated the result of the first round, and ends on Saturday, May 1

English 16-05-2025 08:11

Rhythmic gymnastics: Amalia Lica wins bronze in the hoop event at the European Cup in Burgas

Romanian athlete Amalia Lica won the bronze medal in the hoop event on Thursday at the Rhythmic Gymnastics European Cup in Burgas, with 27.599 points. First ranked was Israeli Meital Maayan Sunkin, with 28.499 points, followed by Bulgarian Dara Stoianova, with 27,866. Bianca Rauta ranked 14th (22.099 points). In the ball event, the first place b

English 15-05-2025 21:55

ForMin Hurezeanu attends informal meeting of foreign ministers of NATO states

Foreign Minister Emil Hurezeanu participated, on Wednesday and Thursday, in the informal meeting of foreign ministers from NATO member states, held in Antalya, Turkey, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MAE) reports. According to the cited source, the meeting focused on the agenda of the NATO Summit in The Hague, which will emphasize increasing defense spending,

English 15-05-2025 20:49

Romanian musicians earn Guinness World Records spot for fastest time to perform on each continent

Violinist Diana Jipa and pianist Stefan Doniga are the first Romanians to perform in Antarctica, but also the ones who bested famous rock band Metallica's world record as the first musicians to perform on all continents within the span of only a year. The Romanian duo concerted on all seven continents in 98 days, approximately 60 days less than the previous record held b

English 15-05-2025 13:23

Over 700 robotics enthusiasts from 13 countries to participate in Oradea Robotics Championship

Bucharest, May 15 /Agerpres/ - Over 700 robotics enthusiasts from 13 countries will participate in the Robotics Championship, taking place at the 'Antonio Alexe' Sports Hall in Oradea, May 16-17. 'The Robotics Championship promotes STEM education in a practical and engaging way, bringing students closer to the world of programming and robotic engin

English 15-05-2025 09:45

Q1 2025 GDP stagnates

The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) stagnated in the first quarter of this year compared to the previous quarter, and compared to the same quarter of 2024, GDP recorded an increase of 0.2%, according to data the National Institute of Statistics (INS) published on Thursday. According to INS, based on seasonally adjusted data, GDP did not change in Q1 2025 compared